Over the following months I’m going to be
posting a series of articles about one of my favourite periods of Doctor Who. Now those reading this who don’t know me will be nodding their head
sagely and muttering ‘Ah yes the Hinchcliffe era no doubt, with it’s wonderful gothic
undertones and brooding performance by Tom Baker.’ Well no I’m afraid not, so
perhaps they're now thinking ‘Well Adam perhaps you’re going to take us through
your own personal journey concerning the master class in base under siege stories that where the Troughton
years.’ again I’m afraid not.1 They may now be furious scratching their heads and saying ‘A look
back at the glory of Pertwee or perhaps yet another spirited defence of the
Graham Williams era?’ Once again dear reader no! The era that I love the most is that of lucky number 7, Sylvester McCoy. Now I’m sure some of you have read that sentence
and just gone ‘Oh....right’ and that’s OK, frankly I’m use to it by now and I bear
no, well very little, resentment. Just the other night I meant a very pleasant
fellow Who lover, who when I mentioned that I was a McCoy fan placed a hand on my
shoulder and just said ‘I’m so sorry’. Now obviously he was joking but it does
underline a certain attitude towards the last 3 years in the original series
run. However the point of these posts will not be to say that people who don’t like McCoy are
wrong, there purpose is to say why I like them and perhaps it’ll provide something of a cathartic exercise for me
personal. That doesn’t mean I’ll be utterly gushing, like every era of Who it
has it has produced its clunkers, but failures can sometimes be more
interesting to examine than success, for such an example you should check out
Tardis Eruditorum’s look back at the 6th Doctor era.
This particular post is too give some personal context as to how I got into Doctor
Who. I was very lucky, I grew up in a Who positive household, my
parents watched the show regularly throughout its original run and I was always aware of its existence.
I was born in 1981 so was around the right age to catch McCoy when he started,
but here’s the thing dear reader I was an overly nervous child so I never properly
watched it. I was aware of McCoy as the Doctor but
never saw him until the first episode of The Curse Of Fenric in 1989,
now in my head I knew it was brilliant but it was also absolutely terrifying so I didn't watch the rest. Who knows perhaps if the original series had gone on for just one more year I’d
have tuned in but could'a should'a would'a is meaningless.3 So Doctor Who was cancelled and that could have been that for me. But
then Doctor Who’s 30th anniversary swung round and they started
showing repeats on BBC 2 and I watched them with my parents and that was how I got to know the
Doctor, by starting with Hartnell and going through to McCoy. Of course I really
liked it but I wasn’t a fan, at least not just yet. Over the next few years I watched a lot
of science fiction and read a lot of comics, sometimes I would go round to
friends and we might watch the occasional video of Who, the Five Doctors for
example, and once I borrowed Silver Nemesis (stop laughing) which I really
enjoyed, especially as it had a cool making of documentary all about Doctor
Who.4 Despite this outrageous flirting I don’t count myself truly becoming a fan until about 1996
when, a few months before the TV Movie, I made a conscious decision to use some
birthday tokens to buy a Doctor Who video, from Boots5, that video was Time And
The Rani and I loved it (no seriously stop laughing!). And that seems as good a
point as any to leave you until the first proper instalment of what I’m going
to be calling Sylvester Sundays.
1. Has anyone ever written
any fan fiction that mashes up series 5 Troughton with the Steven Seagal movie and if not could they do so immediately
please.
2. Though having said that once
I have all the Pertwee on DVD I’ll definitely be doing a similar look back on the era as I
think it’s weirdly misunderstood.
3. It's also the name of a very good Farscape episode.
4. I'm still incredibly sad that they didn't put it as an extra on the Silver Nemesis DVD.
5. Does anyone else remember when Boots used to sell videos? Did any other chemists sell them?
Of course, the title of this blog post immediately gave away which period of Doctor Who you were referring to.
ReplyDeleteFor what it's worth, I agree. Whenever I watch Ghost Light I think to myself "My God, how could they have cancelled it at this point, just as it was getting interesting again?".
Luckily sometime after Doctor Who was cancelled by the BBC, Virgin secured the right to start publishing their adult-oriented New Adventures books, which Cartmel et al used to cover the ground they'd intended to cover with the TV series, albeit without having to worry about not including stuff that would be considered unsuitable for kids...
As someone who thinks the NAs often go too far but who loves the McCoy era in an almost unhealthy way, I am very much looking forward to seeing what you have to say about it. You have many allies, but you were also encounter great resistance among people who formed their opinion of the McCoy era 25 years ago and haven't bothered to revisit it. Convincing those people that they should, or even making them understand why anyone would, is a tall order, but I think you're up to the challenge.
ReplyDeleteAs RuPaul says, "Don't &@*$ it up."
So no pressure then. To be honest I'm not convinced that anyone reading this who hates McCoy will have a moment of revelation but maybe I can just contribute to a critical re-evaluation of it. In the end I've had so many people tell me the reasons they don't like the McCoy era that I just want it on record why I love it.
DeleteI'm with the McCoy Army. And some of my favourite 80s stories in Rememberance and Fenric. I really rate The Happiness Patrol too. It's The Beast Below in all but Doctor and I enjoyed that story *because of the McCoyisms. That I may have projected.
ReplyDelete